With Madera, Looks Are Deceiving at First Glance

King salmon with a salmon sausage at Madera.

Don’t let the ho-hum, earth-tone, low-slung buildings fool you. Nor the location right off the traffic-clogged Sand Hill Road exit off of Interstate 280.

The new Rosewood Sand Hill resort might not look that impressive from the outside. But just step inside.

Its Madera restaurant will catch you off guard with its unexpected sophistication. You’ll practically forget where you are when you step inside the California-elegant dining room with its soaring A-frame wood ceiling, roaring stone fireplace, copper-trimmed open kitchen, and floor-to-ceiling windows that open out onto a terrace with a view of the rolling hills. At sunset, there’s no better seat than one outside. You feel as if you are ensconced at a breathtaking Napa resort.

Rosewood, also the owner of such premier properties as the Mansion on Turtle Creek in Dallas, and the Inn of the Anasazi in Santa Fe, knows how to do warm, comfortable luxuriousness well. And if the recent Saturday night I was invited to dine was any indication, folks on the Peninsula are basking in it, as the restaurant was packed.

The wine service is exceptional. No surprise since the wine program is overseen by Paul Mekis, a veteran of the Plumed Horse in Saratoga, and Aqua in San Francisco. He offers a number of wines by the glass that aren’t usually available that way, including an ’06 Nickel & Nickel Merlot ($25). Varietals are served in the newest line of Riedel stemware, which have unusually thick stems attached to the bowls, giving them a rather bold and modern sensibility, and making them very comfortable to grasp.

Executive Chef Peter Rudolph, formerly of Campton Place in San Francisco and the Ritz-Carlton Half Moon Bay, showcases a menu focused on local, seasonal, and sustainable. In fact, the evening my husband and I were invited in, East Palo Alto farmer David Winsberg of Happy Quail Farms had just given a talk to the kitchen staff about his famed peppers, including Japanese shishitos, that he is supplying to Madera.

As we were seated, the hostess deftly positioned a metal hook on the edge of the table to drape my purse, so that it didn’t have to sit on the floor. Soft, airy house-made focaccia was set down on the table, along with a cube of butter with a well in the center of it that held a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil.

A lovely amuse of crab and radish.

As we perused the a la carte dinner offerings, a creamy-crunchy amuse bouche arrived of crab salad, radish, and turnip puree.

White corn soup with the intense taste of summer.

I started with the glorious white corn soup ($11). A bowl was set down in front of me with rounds of salmon mousse inside. Then, the creamy, sweet soup was poured over it, with the concentrated taste of just-cut-off-the-cob imbued in it.

Crispy veal sweatbreads over a bed of wild mushrooms.

My husband’s veal sweetbreads with lobster mushrooms and white corn ($13) were exceptional, especially because they arrived at the table very hot and crisp, which is not always the case with fried foods at many restaurants.

My King salmon ($31) was cooked perfectly medium-rare, with the chermoula on top adding a zesty brightness. The server explained that the chef likes to add sausage to fish dishes, so accompanying my salmon fillet also was a juicy salmon sausage. Summer squash and squash blossoms lay on top of a mole-like sauce on the plate. Everything was cooked technically well, but perhaps there was just a bit too much going on the plate. Indeed, once you tasted the assertive mole-like sauce, which was a good-size puddle and not a mere squiggle on the plate, your taste buds grew numb to the wonderful nuances of the fine piece of wild salmon.

A big, juicy rib eye crowned with summer veggies and blue cheese.

My husband had a similar issue with his oak-grilled rib eye that was piled high with mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, shishito peppers and chunks of blue cheese ($34). The steak was juicy, tender, and with a big, beefy taste. But at times, it got lost underneath everything else.

Other diners apparently also have made mention of the dishes being too complicated, and the kitchen is in the process of adjusting. Less would definitely add up to more here. Leaving one or two things off the plate would really make the food shine even brighter.

Tender olive oil cake that came to the table already split in two, since we were sharing.

From the list of $10 desserts, we chose the olive oil cake with lemon verbena, creme fraiche sherbet, and Moscato peaches. The stone fruit was cooked-sous vide with the fortified wine, giving them a brilliant pink hue. The method also allowed the peaches to keep their shape better and remain slightly crisp, while still tender.

The mignardise will make you giggle — chocolate almond bark alongside a small bowl of sweet, crunchy, kid-like caramel corn. When’s the last time you saw that at a white-tablecloth restaurant?

Madera takes itself seriously in all the right places, and knows precisely when to add a bit of whimsy to banish any air of stuffiness. As we munched on the last of the kernels of caramel corn, and night descended upon the serene hills, it was hard to think about leaving such a pampering spot that wondrously makes you feel as if you’re somewhere you’re not.

Ending the evening with house-made caramel corn.

Print This Post



10 comments

  • How strong is the influence of the Spanish language: Madera (Wood) Restaurant!
    In my country this type of tasty places could be named also as sophisticated Resto-Parrilladas.

    Ohh I need to go to this Resort! Has the first photo a chorizo? It seems a Latin-style on this place.
    The creamy corn-salmon soup worth to repeat it several times 🙂

    Cheers!

    Gera

  • Hi Gera: Nope, the sausage in the first photo is made out of salmon. And it was quite tasty, too.

  • Recession? What recession?! We were recently at a similarly swanky peninsula restaurant just up the road in Woodside. On a Monday night, no less, there was not a single empty table. Madera’s menu looks absolutely wonderful. If diners around here are the least bit depressed at the the condition of their portfolios, I suspect they will find new meaning to the words “comfort food” in places like that. How lovely that your were so well-pampered, Carolyn!

  • Carolyn – did they know who you were, or did you go incognito? I wonder if the kitchen did a better job on the food for you than for us because they knew you were a reviewer?

    My hubby and I had a very expensive dinner and a very expensive breakfast there a couple of weeks ago, and both meals were terribly disappointing for all the dishes, both in quality of ingredients (e.g., three tiny, tired, dry pieces of lobster in my lobster salad) and cooking technique (e.g., very greasy and burnt hash for breakfast). The service, location, and decor were very nice, but we cannot justify a return visit at any price for such poor quality, much less at those prices.

    The hotel’s gift shop is wonderful, though – and very dangerous on the wallet!

  • Claudette: Oh no, about your experiences at Madera. That sounds awful. In answer to your question, yes, they did know I was a food writer when I came in to dine. In fact, as I mentioned in the post, the restaurant folks actually invited me to come try the food there. So yes, I’m sure that makes them more careful about the cooking and service then. I hope yours was an isolated experience and that the restaurant staff is taking pains to be at the top of their game no matter who is in the restaurant.

  • Wow, what a great meal! Glad you gave them a chance. I have to say, I am guilt of judging a restaurant by its appearance. Well, Cheesecake Factory look really good from the outside, but the food is average at best.
    That amuse buche looks like a pink fish! SO pretty!

  • Well if the food is as good as your photography – I’ll go!

    –Marc

  • Hey, what happened to Mark Bittman ice cream post? I was looking forward to reading that one! 🙂

  • Erin: A technical malfunction. Hah. Look for it to post this coming Friday morning. 😉

  • Wow, just the way you describe everything makes me want to be there!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *