Cookie Mixes From a Mother-Daughter Duo

Oatmeal-cranberry cookies -- from a mix.

“Healthier homemade” was Susan Nolte’s mantra when she came up with her line of cookie mixes in Connecticut four years ago.

Made with rolled oats and whole wheat flour, these convenient mixes are now available on this coast at many farmers markets and stores in Southern California, thanks to her daughter, Marissa, who started managing business development for the company.

May Cookie Co., named after Susan Nolte’s great-grandmother, makes three types of cookie mixes: Triple Chocolate Oatmeal, Oatmeal Cranberry and the vegan Chocolate Chocolate Chip.

Recently, I had a chance to try samples of the mixes.

Choose from three different varieties.The Chocolate Chocolate Chip mix requires the addition of oil, vanilla extract and soy milk, rice milk or almond milk. The resulting dough is very thick and dry, so much so that you really have to work at it to get it to hold together and to incorporate the chips thoroughly. They bake up with a quite fudgy texture.

The Oatmeal Cranberry was probably my favorite because the sweet-tart dried berries married so well with the hearty nature of the cookie. You add butter, an egg and vanilla extract to the mix. The cookies are thick, soft and buttery. And they get chewier as they cool.

Each mix makes about 24 small cookies, each about three bites worth. If you’re a from-scratch baker, these probably won’t make you switch. But if you’re time-pressed baker who prefers a helping hand, these are a handy alternative.

A box sells for $8.99 or three boxes for $24 online at Abe’s Market.

A beautiful bundt. (Photo courtesy of Nothing Bundt Cakes)

Winner of Last Week’s Contest: In the most recent Food Gal contest, I asked you to tell me your favorite memory that involves cake. The winner will receive a gift card good for one free Nothing Bundt Cake individual Bundlet every month for a year, which must be picked up at the new Nothing Bundt Cake bakery in Fremont.

Congrats to:

Diane, who wrote, “My favorite memory about cake was when I was about 10 or 11. My dad loved maraschino cherry cake and I loved to get a store boxed cake mix and add the cherries to the cake mix. I did this many times for him and he got the biggest kick out of eating a cake that I had made for him. He would sit reading the newspaper while I had a big wooden spoon that I used to mix up the batter and then he would supervise as to how many cherries I should use to put in the cake. Then, one year, Christmas arrived and there were quite a few wrapped presents under the tree for me, way more than usual. My dad handed me one present and asked that I open it first. It was an electric mixer, then he handed me another present and it was a cake mix and another and another present until I had unwrapped about 30 individual Betty Crocker cakes mixes. My dad was glowing from ear to ear. The one final present that he had especially wrapped for me was a huge jar of, you guessed it, maraschino cherries. I did get other gifts that year but I don’t think any of them meant as much to me as all those individually wrapped cake mixes. My dad passed away many years ago but I would give anything to bake him another maraschino cherry cake. I will never forget that Christmas morning with all those cake mixes stacked up around me and my dad’s beaming smile as I got busy with my new electric mixer and baked him a beautiful Christmas Maraschino Cherry Cake. Ahhh, such good memories.”

More Cookie Mixes to Try: Bakesale Betty’s Ginger Molasses Cookie Mix

And: Baked Brownie and Blondie Mixes

Share and Enjoy
Print This Post
Tags »

Date: Monday, 16. January 2012 5:26
Trackback: Trackback-URL Category: Chocolate, General, New Products

Feed for the post RSS 2.0 Comment this post


  1. 1

    Think I’ll stick with homemade and fattening. I’m getting too old to change!

  2. 2

    With my current cholesterol levels, I need to switch to eating these cookies!

  3. 3

    Those cookie mixes look great! Might be useful to help kick 2012 of with a good start :)

  4. 4

    What great flavours of cookie mix. What a shame we can’t buy those here in Australia.

  5. 5

    Oatmeal and cranberries sound good to me :-)
    Have a great week ahead Carolyn!

  6. 6

    I love dense, heaty oatmeal cookies. They actually make me feel like I’m eating a healthier cookie (ok I know this logic is flawed perhaps but not in this cookie’s case!).

  7. 7

    I love these types of cookies, it makes me feel like I’m being healthy, so I can eat more :) lol.

  8. 8

    It’s rare to find cake/cookie mixes that are actually not full of weirdo ingredients but these sound awesome! Definitely need to check them out!

  9. 9

    […] More Cookie Mixes: May Cookie Co. […]

Submit comment

Current ye@r *