Healdsburg’s Dry Creek Kitchen Celebrates 25 Years

The statement-making 50-layer lasagna at Dry Creek Kitchen.
The statement-making 50-layer lasagna at Dry Creek Kitchen.

Shane McAnelly knew he wanted to be a chef even long before winning “Best in Show” at the Contra Costa County Fair with his ambitious three-layer cheesecake — at age 15.

Oh yeah, he did.

Growing up baking with his mom and grandma instilled him a passion that only grew when he took a job at 17 as a fry cook at Applebee’s, then got his culinary degree at Diablo Valley College before going on to work at Blackhawk Grille in Danville, Garibaldi’s in San Francisco, Zero Zero in San Francisco, Va de Vi in Walnut Creek, Chalkboard in Healdsburg, and Brass Rabbit in Healdsburg.

For the past three years, the 44-year-old Bay Area native has helmed the kitchen at Healdsburg’s Dry Creek Kitchen. He couldn’t be more thrilled to be its executive chef as the trailblazing restaurant founded by culinary icon Charlie Palmer celebrates its 25th anniversary this year.

“It’s great to be part of this family here,” he said when I was invited in as a guest of the restaurant last week. “You can’t ask for better than to have the godfather of cuisine as your boss.”

Executive Chef Shane McAnelly
Executive Chef Shane McAnelly.

When Hotel Healdsburg and its Dry Creek Kitchen restaurant opened a quarter century ago, downtown Healdsburg was far from the upscale Wine Country destination that it is today.

Developer Merritt Sher, who had made a name for himself building shopping centers, would drive up to the quiet, sleepy town with his wife Pam Merritt from their home in Marin County. One day, he spied an empty property on the square, and the wheels started turning. Although he had no experience in building a boutique hotel, he had the confidence to pull it off.

What sealed the deal? Landing celebrated chef Palmer, who had already kicked around the idea of moving from New York with his family to agrarian Healdsburg, to operate the hotel’s restaurant.

It opened in 2001. Right after 9/11.

With that unfortunate timing, people predicted doomsday for the new property. But then a curious thing happened.

“My dad had put so much of his own money into it because nobody was going to loan money to a first-time hotel builder. When it opened, we thought nobody was going to come because nobody was traveling,” remembered his daughter Circe Sher, now co-owner of Hotel Healdsburg and president of Piazza Hospitality, which also developed and manages H2Hotel, Spoonbar restaurant, Pizzando restaurant, and Harmon Guest House, all in Healdsburg, and Hotel San Luis Obispo on the Central Coast. “But it drew people from the Bay Area immediately, who were eager for staycations.”

The entrance to the restaurant.
The entrance to the restaurant.
The dining room.
The dining room.

The success of the hotel and the restaurant paved the way for other upscale restaurants and accommodations that lured even more visitors from all over to the still quaint yet now buzzy town.

I always find Healdsburg a particularly wonderful place to visit in late-fall or winter, when the crowds of tourists have thinned, the air is crisp, and sparkly holiday lights are up. What’s more, the Hotel Healdsburg is not only starting up its festive “Holiday Tea,” but also offering a special anniversary package through 2027 for a two-night stay that includes a $250 property credit plus a commemorative etched bottle of Iron Horse Sparkling Cuvée to commemorate the hotel’s milestone anniversary.

Dry Creek Kitchen offers a six-course $155 per person chef’s tasting menu nightly, with an optional $85 wine pairing; or a three-course $87 per person prix fixe with optional supplemental canapes.

An apple-ginger welcoming cocktail.
An apple-ginger welcoming cocktail.
Caviar and hash brown.
Caviar and hash brown.

McAnelly actually created a hybrid for me, sticking to most of the courses on the tasting menu but allowing me to sub in a few of his pasta dishes. After all, when a chef tells me, a total carb lover, that he absolutely loves making pastas, you know I have to make room for them. Palmer used to enjoy McAnelly’s pastas at Chalkboard, so he was only too eager to have them served at Dry Creek Kitchen.

The evening began with glasses of sparkling wine mixed with ginger and apple greeted us, a taste of late-autumn, along with indulgent two-bite hash browns topped with French onion dip and Tsar Nicolai caviar ($39).

Then, came canapes of pie tee ($9 for two), delicate fried Malaysian rice-flour pastry cups filled with ricotta, beets, avocado and pistachios for a big crunch with earthy flavors.

Pie tee canapes.
Pie tee canapes.
Focaccia.
Focaccia.

Focaccia followed, looking at first glance like Parker House rolls. But once you tasted the olive oil and chives in the bread with its thin yet crisp exterior and fluffy interior, its identity revealed itself immediately.

Lush slices of kanpachi were served crudo-style, with Meyer lemon, white soy sauce and Asian pear that really brought out its fresh, bright taste.

Kanpachi crudo.
Kanpachi crudo.

Having just gotten in a delivery of spiny lobster, McAnelly offered up a special dish with its sweet flesh adorning strands of linguine in a simple yet on-point sauce of butter, chives, and saffron with just enough fresh lemon juice to add a perky finish. My husband and I shared this dish, though, I would have happily hoarded every last bite to myself.

‘Nduja (spicy spreadable sausage) from nearby Journeyman Meat Co. caressed nuvole or short, rippled pasta with Gulf shrimp that got a Korean spin with gochujang mixed in with with lobster stock to create a spicy dish with concentrated seafood flavor plus a hint of fermented funkiness.

Spiny lobster linguine.
Spiny lobster linguini.
Italian-Korean nuvole.
Italian-Korean nuvole.

Then, came the piece de resistance, the beast, the huge 50-layer lasagna that never comes off the prix-fixe menu without a revolt from diners.

Is it truly 50 layers? If you count everything — the pasta sheets, bechamel, San Marzano tomatoes, bolognese sauce, and mozzarella — it is, McAnelly said. A 6-inch square pan of it weighs 50 pounds. It can take an hour and a half to construct, a fact that his 12-year-old son Jackie found out when he helped his dad put one together. For his efforts, MAnelly renamed it for a time on the menu as “Jackie’s 50-Layer Lasagna.”

It’s a formidable sight when it comes to the table with the elongated brick stretching across the plate, revealing its striations. McAnelly can’t help himself, so it actually comes crowned with a slab of focaccia blanketed in creamy Italian stracciatella cheese dotted with pesto.

It’s rich, hearty, homey, and will definitely fill you up. I especially liked the charred crispy edges.

That was followed by Iberico pork roulade, tender, smoky, and almost ham-like in taste, that was served with quince and a mustard sauce.

Iberico pork.
Iberico pork.
"Surf & Turf.''
“Surf & Turf.”

The last savory course, also part of the tasting menu, was “Surf & Turf,” prime filet mignon grilled over binchotan, leaving it smoky and moist, that was paired with a round lobster ravioli made with a thin, supple pasta sheet. The deeply savory steak sauce was so satisfying that I found myself dipping part of the ravioli into it, too.

There’s cheesecake to end the night — not McAnelly’s but that of Pastry Chef Taylor Kelly. It’s a fine rendition, too, that is creamy and luscious, but somehow eats a little lighter than the usual cheesecake. The cinnamon buttermilk cheesecake is full of holiday flavors with a brown butter graham crust, cider-poached pears, cookie butter whipped ganache, and speculoos streusel.

Cinnamon buttermilk cheesecake.
Cinnamon buttermilk cheesecake.
Mignardises.
Mignardises.

It’s served alongside mignardises of financiers, chocolates, and teeny torched meringue-topped lemon tarts.

Congratulations, Dry Creek Kitchen, on setting the standard for all that was to come. Here’s to another brilliant 25 years.

Print This Post



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *