Musings on Peach-Nectarine Buttermilk Ice Cream

Buttermilk ice cream with chunks of peaches and nectarines.

Buttermilk ice cream with chunks of peaches and nectarines.

I have done a very dangerous thing.

I have taken the plunge to buy an ice cream machine.

My freezer’s not going to know what hit it.

For years, I contemplated buying an ice cream machine because, well, who doesn’t love ice cream? But each time the temptation hit, I pushed it aside, fearing I’d be making ice cream all the time if it was that convenient. And well, eating ice cream all the time does have its consequences.

But as I started work on my first cookbook, “San Francisco Chef’s Table” (Lyons Press), which will publish in November, I realized I would need to test the ice cream recipes from the chefs contributing to the book.

I could no longer say “no” to the Cuisinart ice cream maker that I’d coveted.

I did the deed a couple weeks ago. And I’ve already used the dang thing three times. God, help me.

Because making your own ice cream couldn’t be easier. You just stir up an ice cream base of some sort, made with cream or milk or buttermilk, and egg yolks or not. Chill it overnight to get it really cold. Set up the ice cream maker, the bowl of which you’ve had in the freezer at least 24 hours. Turn on the machine, pour the base into it and let it go to town. Admittedly, the first 7 minutes are like watching paint dry. Not much happens. But slowly, but surely, the mixture starts to thicken and freeze, turning into scoop-able ice cream that you can stick back into the freezer to firm up even more.

My new toy.

My new toy.

There she is, hard at work.

There she is, hard at work.

Since this is optimum stone fruit time, I couldn’t resist making a batch of “Peach-Nectarine Buttermilk Ice Cream” from “The Animal Farm Buttermilk Cookbook” (Andrews McMeel), of which I received a review copy. Author Diane St. Clair is the owner of the farm that supplies butter to the French Laundry in Yountville.

The original recipe calls for just peaches. But since I had both peaches and nectarines at home, I decided to use a mix.

The dash of almond extract is a brilliant touch because it mimics the flavor of a peach pit, heightening the peach flavor all together.

Buttermilk makes this ice cream a little more virtuous in the calorie department. It also contributes a refreshing tang, making this ice cream taste very much like a peach-nectarine yogurt smoothie.

It’s a perfect treat for this time of year.

If you don’t yet have an ice cream maker, far be it from me to tell you to buy one.

But I’m sure glad I gave in. Finally.


Peach-Nectarine Buttermilk Ice Cream

(Makes 1 1/2 quarts)

8 small ripe peaches, nectarines or a mix of both (2 to 2 1/2 pounds)

3 cups buttermilk

1 cup sugar

1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

1/4 teaspoon almond extract

Bring a large pot of water to a boil. Using a slotted spoon, dunk the peaches and nectarines in the boiling water until the skins split and can be easily removed. Drop them in a bowl of ice water and slip off the skins. Discard the pit, chop the flesh, and put it in the bowl of a food processor or a blender.

Add 1 cup buttermilk and pulse until mostly smooth, with only a few chunks of peach remaining.

Transfer the pureed peaches to a large bowl and add the remaining 2 cups of buttermilk, the sugar, lemon juice, vanilla, and almond extract. Cover and chill in the refrigerator for several hours, until very cold.

Freeze in an ice-cream maker according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Press plastic wrap on the surface of any leftover ice cram and it will stay fresh in the freezer for a week.

Adapted from “The Animal Farm Buttermilk Cookbook” by Diane St. Clair


Another Recipe from The Animal Farm Buttermilk Cookbook: Buttermilk-Coconut Blondies

Print This Post


  • This ice cream is really original! It must taste divine. A wonderfully refreshing summer treat.



  • Ooooh, I’m so jealous. I too have contemplated getting an ice cream machine, mostly because I think you can be so creative with ice cream flavors so it would be fun creating new ideas for flavor. But then I always worry I’d be making too much ice cream for a single guy! For now, I’m going to just live vicariously through you. Can’t wait to hear about your next flavor!

  • The bowl for our ice cream maker lives in our freezer at this time of the year – that way we’re ready to make ice cream anytime we want! And it’s so nice coming up with your own flavors, and in particular using fresh fruit. There’s no going back, alas – you’re hooked!

  • My girlfriend bought one of these many years ago and man, we had a blast making all sorts of fancy ice cream. Unfortunately for our hips, we also gained a ton of calories. LOL!

  • and what a beautiful delicious plunge it is!

  • Oh Carolyn, I never thought in making ice cream with buttermilk…this peach/nectarine ice cream looks delicious and so aromatic.
    Thanks for the recipe and hope you are having a lovely week πŸ˜€

  • I love buttermilk. This ice cream sounds so refreshing!

  • Your post made me laugh out loud! What I wouldn’t give for an excuse like that to say to my husband: But I really need an ice cream maker for professional reasons! I dream of owning one and, like you, I’d be making ice cream all the time! A buttermilk and stone fruit ice cream sounds like the ideal summer treat!

  • Yay….happy you jump on the making homemade ice cream bandwagon! I know it is dangerous because I’ve been making ice cream all year round ever since I got my machine! But hey, at least you have a valid reason to justify getting one…I did it just for the love of ice cream! hahaha….Have fun churning and I can’t wait to try this Peach and Nectarine Buttermilk ice cream…never try an ice cream with buttermilk in it yet. πŸ™‚

  • What a lovely looking book all about buttermilk! Yummm! That ice-cream looks very delectable & creamy too! Yummmm!

  • i refuse to get an ice cream machine. i’m waiting for someone, anyone to get one for me. πŸ™‚
    love this flavor!

  • Woo-hoo, welcome to the ice cream maker owner club! I remember making batch after batch of ice cream when I first bought mine… good times. It’s currently gathering a bit of dust, but this looks like the perfect recipe to bring it back into ice cream making business! πŸ™‚

  • Ah yes….buttermilk ice cream! One of my favorites!

  • Buying that ice cream maker was a dangerously AMAZING thing to do. That peach-necartine ice cream sounds heavenly. Make an ice cream with chocolate next, please! πŸ˜€

  • Liz: A gal after my own heart. LOL Mmm, chocolate ice cream will definitely get a workout in that new machine.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *